The Top Interview Questions to Hire a Social Media Manager

""

Evidenced

7

min read

|

14 Aug 2024

Need help assessing

a Social Media Manager

?

Social media phones

You know how crucial a social media manager is for your company's online presence. They're the ones who not only keep your brand voice consistent across various platforms but also strategise to keep your audience engaged. You might have the passion, but hiring the right social media manager involves asking the right questions to assess their experience and skills. This article aims to arm you with the perfect set of questions to ensure your candidates fit the bill. So, let's dive in!

1. Evaluating Experience and Skills

1.1 What platforms have you managed?

When evaluating a candidate's experience, the platforms they've worked on can say a lot about their abilities. Ask them to list the social media platforms they've managed. Common platforms include Facebook, Instagram, X (formally Twitter), LinkedIn, Pinterest, and TikTok. Each platform has its own nuances, audience, and content strategy. By understanding their experience, you can gauge how well they can adapt their skills to your needs.

Why it matters: A candidate with broad platform experience shows versatility. They should be able to explain the differences in content strategy, engagement tactics, and audience demographics for each platform. If they’ve only managed one or two platforms, they might not have the adaptability you need.

Pro-tip: Ask about specific features on each platform, such as Instagram Stories or TikTok trends. This will give you insights into their depth of knowledge.

1.2 Describe a successful campaign you've run.

Knowing the nuts and bolts of a well-executed campaign is fundamental for a social media manager. Ask them to detail a successful campaign, from conception to execution to results. Look for specifics such as campaign objectives, target audience, content strategy, and metrics used to measure success.

Why it matters: Their answer will show their understanding of campaign planning and execution. You want to see if they set clear goals and if they know how to measure success. Were they aiming for brand awareness, increased engagement, or driving sales? Specific metrics like engagement rate, click-through rate, or conversions can illustrate the campaign's success.

Pro-tip: Ask for examples with clear figures, like “We increased engagement by 20% over three months by using a targeted Instagram campaign.”

1.3 How do you measure social media success?

Measuring social media success isn't just about counting likes and followers. A seasoned social media manager should use a variety of metrics to gauge performance. Ask them which metrics they consider essential. Common metrics include engagement rate, reach, impressions, click-through rate (CTR), and conversions.

Why it matters: You'll want to know if their definition of success aligns with your company's goals. Metrics like engagement rate and CTR can indicate how well content resonates with the audience, while conversions and ROI might be more crucial for sales-driven campaigns.

Pro-tip: Ask how they use tools like Google Analytics, Hootsuite, or Sprout Social to track these metrics. This shows their technical proficiency in measuring, analysing, and adjusting strategies for better outcomes.

2. Understanding Strategy and Creativity

2.1 How do you stay updated with social media trends?

To stay updated with social media trends, a social media manager should follow industry thought leaders on platforms like LinkedIn and Twitter. Subscribing to newsletters from reputable sources such as Social Media Examiner, and reading blogs from Hootsuite or Sprout Social can help you stay informed. Additionally, joining online communities and attending webinars or conferences can provide insights into the latest strategies and tools.

It's useful to track algorithm updates from major platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter. This ensures that your strategies remain effective. Using tools like Google Alerts for keywords related to social media trends and leveraging analytics tools can also help identify emerging trends based on data.

Pro-tip: Create a dedicated folder in your email for newsletters and articles to easily reference the latest updates and trends.

2.2 Explain how you tailor content for different social media platforms.

Content must be tailored to fit the specific audience and format of each social media platform. For instance, Instagram favours visually appealing images and short videos with engaging captions. In contrast, LinkedIn is more professional, with long-form articles and industry-related content performing well. Facebook allows for a mix of text, images, and videos, and interactive content like polls and live streams.

Identifying the audience demographics and behaviours on each platform is crucial. Twitter, for example, calls for concise, quick updates due to its character limit, making it great for news and real-time engagement. TikTok’s format favours creative, short-form video content that often includes trending sounds or challenges.

Pro-tip: Use data-driven insights from each platform's analytics to understand what type of content resonates best with your audience on that specific platform.

2.3 Describe your process for creating a social media calendar.

Creating a social media calendar begins with setting clear goals for what you want to achieve through your campaigns, whether it's increasing engagement, driving website traffic, or boosting brand awareness. Start by conducting a content audit to understand what has worked in the past and identifying any content gaps.

Break down your content into categories such as blog posts, user-generated content, promotional material, and seasonal posts. Using tools like Trello, Google Sheets, or specialised software like CoSchedule can help in organising your calendar. Ensure to schedule regular reviews of your calendar to adjust your strategy based on performance analytics.

Pro-tip: Incorporate key dates and holidays relevant to your industry into your calendar to ensure timely and relevant content creation.

3. Top Interview Questions to Assess Collaboration and Adaptability

3.1 How do you handle negative feedback online?

Handling negative feedback is crucial for any social media manager. Look for candidates who detail a structured and calm approach. They should mention acknowledging the feedback quickly and responding respectfully. It's essential they provide real examples, such as addressing a customer’s complaint on Facebook by offering a resolution or directing them to a support team.

Candidates should mention the importance of monitoring discussions and ensuring issues are resolved timely. Prompt follow-ups and dealing with repetitive feedback demonstrate their ability to maintain a positive brand image. Emphasise the need for documenting incidents to avoid future issues and sharing insights with the team for continuous improvement.

Pro-tip: Use sentiment analysis tools like Brandwatch to keep track of customer opinions and quickly address any negative trends.

3.2 Can you give an example of adapting to a social media crisis?

In social media management, crises are inevitable. Strong candidates should share real-life examples of unexpected events affecting the brand negatively. Look for strategic thinking in their responses. Did they pause scheduled posts? Did they craft a unified response plan? Specificity is key—mention a crisis like a product recall or a controversial post.

Their response should include steps like analysing the issue, communicating with stakeholders, and utilising various channels to manage the crisis. Did they use X (formally Twitter) for rapid updates or email newsletters for detailed apologies? Candidates should reveal their ability to stay composed under pressure and work collaboratively with PR teams.

Pro-tip: Implement social listening tools like Hootsuite Insights to track crises in real time and respond effectively.

3.3 Describe your experience working with cross-functional teams.

Cross-functional teamwork is crucial in social media roles. Your ideal candidate should illustrate their experience collaborating with different departments like Marketing, Sales, and Customer Support. They might discuss working with the content team to create engaging posts or coordinating with customer service for timely issue resolution.

Assess how they manage task delegation and share information seamlessly across teams. Do they use tools like Trello or Slack for effective communication? Look for mentions of regular meetings and feedback sessions. An ability to understand and align social media goals with broader company objectives reflects adaptability and a cooperative mindset.

Pro-tip: Encourage the use of project management tools like Asana to streamline multi-departmental projects.


Effective collaboration and adaptability in social media management are non-negotiable skills. As you prepare to interview candidates, focus on how they handle crises, negative feedback, and teamwork to ensure they're the right fit for your company.

Want to run this type of interview?

Evidenced is packed with pre-built templates and questions to let you run perfectly structured interviews.

Frequently Asked Questions

What to look out for when hiring a social media manager?

Look for:

  • Proven experience managing multiple platforms

  • Strong examples of successful campaigns

  • Strategic thinking and creativity

  • Ability to handle crises and negative feedback

  • Great collaboration skills with various teams

How do I prepare for a social media manager interview?

  • Review the candidate's portfolio and past campaigns

  • Prepare platform-specific questions

  • Test their knowledge of the latest social media trends

  • Ask about their strategy for content creation and scheduling

  • Gauge their crisis management skills

How do I recruit a social media manager?

  • Post detailed job descriptions on platforms like LinkedIn

  • Include key skills and experience required

  • Use applicant tracking systems to streamline the process

  • Check for relevant certifications (e.g., Hootsuite Certified)

  • Conduct multiple interview rounds to assess fit

How do I choose a good social media manager?

  • Look for relevant industry experience

  • Check for successful campaign case studies

  • Ensure they have strong analytical skills

  • Assess their ability to stay updated with trends

  • Verify their teamwork and project management skills